@Pilgrim past a certain point it becomes easily explainable via the "investment fallacy" aka "sunk cost fallacy". Having expended a certain amount of time and energy in a point of view, abandoning the point of view often translates into feeling one has wasted their time / energy. There is a protectionism measure there too in many cases.
Not saying this is why people choose to continue to believe, or why Nav believes in this case, but it could be part of it in many such similar cases. I think it is more efficient to cut ones losses, and allow a shift in perspective once the bar of proof (or lack thereof) has been met, but therein lies the rub, because for some people, that which meets the bar of proof (or disproof), is not the same as for others. To put it in simple terms, some don't believe in science, or only believe in parts of it, or only those parts they find useful at a certain time. It's all just playing with beliefs, picking and choosing what fits best at certain times, in order to support another belief. Cherry-picked belief laddering. The problem is that as soon as one chooses to use certain evidence as proof, they have to accept that other things that belong to that class of evidence are also legitimate, even if they disprove what they believe. It's a cognitive dissonance then to realize that you aren't basing your beliefs on the proof, you are basing your chosen "proofs" on your pre-existing belief.
I've said it before and I will reiterate it here - alchemy does not need magic tricks, illusionists, con-men, grifters, or any sort of that stuff. That at times it attracts these types is understandable - all "esoteric" systems attract them, and in a larger way, you find these types everywhere that there is possibility of money, fame, power, bolstering the ego, selling things, convincing others, and so on. It's a ubiquitous aspect of human nature.
I think it cheapens the whole thing immensely. It's like the American white house, with all the decorations that are just spray-painted gold. It's fucking tacky and cheap, and only serves to convince certain types, and to many others it's actually deeply repulsive. There are processes that deal with matter that are unconventional, or unexplored in modern chemistry, and processes that can yield unusual results, and even processes that are just repetitions of things that have no immediate change that over long time creates a change. These things are real, even in the most strict chemical / material sense, and don't need showmanship to dress it up. The problem is, these things don't attract much attention, and you can't make a TV special about the supernatural based on the idea that repeated dissolutions and coagulations of some metal salt in water will, over long periods of time
slightly change the material characteristics of that salt.
There is another aspect to all these things, a bit of a meta-perspective on us humans, and that is we go through various phases of interacting with our own beliefs as we explore the world around us, the world of ideas, the world of alchemy, the spirit world, our internal world with its various layers, and so on. Often times, progress is made by pigeonholing, that is, by assumption of things as if they were true, which serve as a foot-hold or a rung on a ladder in order to progress our understanding to some other step. Within these types of steps, sometimes treating something as 100% real is important for the development of some next step, and others, from the outside, trying to convince you otherwise is perhaps not helpful for what you are personally going through, as it's not really about the empirical validity of the thing you believe to be true, rather its about that belief inside yourself and the unseen transformations it is undergoing.
@nav2010 none of this is directed towards you or meant to be read in any sort of negative light, it is a light-hearted response to
@Pilgrim exploring some concepts related to the divides in belief.