Chanfray's second transmutation live on Spanish TV

Pilgrim

Hermes Trismegistus
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 26, 2023
Messages
1,257
Hi Nav

You've totally ignored my point so I'll make it again. AFAIK doing transmutations of metals involves actually melting the metal in question, hence the alchemy text quotes I provided.

The notion that someone put marks on the lead beforehand and then had something afterward that also had the marks is utterly absurd IF the base metal is required to be melted. The lead was in the pot for over 4 mins on a gas burner. Don't you think that would have resulted in the lead melting?
 

nav2010

Occultum
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
752
Hi Nav

You've totally ignored my point so I'll make it again. AFAIK doing transmutations of metals involves actually melting the metal in question, hence the alchemy text quotes I provided.

The notion that someone put marks on the lead beforehand and then had something afterward that also had the marks is utterly absurd IF the base metal is required to be melted. The lead was in the pot for over 4 mins on a gas burner. Don't you think that would have resulted in the lead melting?
Why? have you witnessed a live transmutation and observed it needs to be melted?
You're only going on the words of others and there are more red herrings in alchemy than the north sea.
 

Seth-Ra

Lapidem
Honorable Meister
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 1, 2009
Messages
1,176
Why? have you witnessed a live transmutation and observed it needs to be melted?

I know this wasn't asked of me and that I'm "butting in" here, forgive me, but to answer this part; yes, and yes.
For the metal to be open to change, it needs to be in flux. Even if the Stone or lesser catalyst were to possess the ingress to open and penetrate the lesser metal while it was still cold and fixed, the act of ingressing into it and changing it would still "deform" it from its original fixed form. Superficial/mechanically made marks on the lesser, would not be present in the end.

Different materials or catalysts can be used to gold-plate an object, whereby the fixed lesser material can stay solid and with its marks, while appearing to be gold and having real gold on it, but its core wouldn't be changed.

This whole thing has the appearance and hallmarks of stage magic and not real alchemy, imo/ime.

~Seth-Ra
 

nav2010

Occultum
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
752
I know this wasn't asked of me and that I'm "butting in" here, forgive me, but to answer this part; yes, and yes.
For the metal to be open to change, it needs to be in flux. Even if the Stone or lesser catalyst were to possess the ingress to open and penetrate the lesser metal while it was still cold and fixed, the act of ingressing into it and changing it would still "deform" it from its original fixed form. Superficial/mechanically made marks on the lesser, would not be present in the end.

Different materials or catalysts can be used to gold-plate an object, whereby the fixed lesser material can stay solid and with its marks, while appearing to be gold and having real gold on it, but its core wouldn't be changed.

This whole thing has the appearance and hallmarks of stage magic and not real alchemy, imo/ime.

~Seth-Ra
They cut the gold, filed off the outer and it wasn't plated.
 

Pilgrim

Hermes Trismegistus
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 26, 2023
Messages
1,257
Again you're ignoring the physics of melting lead.

Here's a vid of a guy melting huge pieces of lead in a crucible over a similar sized butane gas burner. The "cooking" begins at 3min in and about 1 min 50sec later you can visibly see molten lead in the bottom of the crucible. This is with an OPEN pot which is very inefficient in terms of heat wastage, like boiling a pan of potatoes on your kitchen stove without outting a lid on the pan.


Chanfrey's demonstration used an absolutely miniscule piece of wire lead which was in a closed crucible for OVER 4 MINUTES !

I have a great deal of respect for you Nav and your Singlet Oxygen work, but I can not for the life of me fathom how you could be bamboozled into thinking that a tiny piece of lead wire in a closed crucible subjected to butane gas heat for over 4 minutes would not melt.
 

Lux Natura

Occultum
Honorable Meister
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Aug 25, 2016
Messages
675
@Pilgrim past a certain point it becomes easily explainable via the "investment fallacy" aka "sunk cost fallacy". Having expended a certain amount of time and energy in a point of view, abandoning the point of view often translates into feeling one has wasted their time / energy. There is a protectionism measure there too in many cases.

Not saying this is why people choose to continue to believe, or why Nav believes in this case, but it could be part of it in many such similar cases. I think it is more efficient to cut ones losses, and allow a shift in perspective once the bar of proof (or lack thereof) has been met, but therein lies the rub, because for some people, that which meets the bar of proof (or disproof), is not the same as for others. To put it in simple terms, some don't believe in science, or only believe in parts of it, or only those parts they find useful at a certain time. It's all just playing with beliefs, picking and choosing what fits best at certain times, in order to support another belief. Cherry-picked belief laddering. The problem is that as soon as one chooses to use certain evidence as proof, they have to accept that other things that belong to that class of evidence are also legitimate, even if they disprove what they believe. It's a cognitive dissonance then to realize that you aren't basing your beliefs on the proof, you are basing your chosen "proofs" on your pre-existing belief.


I've said it before and I will reiterate it here - alchemy does not need magic tricks, illusionists, con-men, grifters, or any sort of that stuff. That at times it attracts these types is understandable - all "esoteric" systems attract them, and in a larger way, you find these types everywhere that there is possibility of money, fame, power, bolstering the ego, selling things, convincing others, and so on. It's a ubiquitous aspect of human nature.

I think it cheapens the whole thing immensely. It's like the American white house, with all the decorations that are just spray-painted gold. It's fucking tacky and cheap, and only serves to convince certain types, and to many others it's actually deeply repulsive. There are processes that deal with matter that are unconventional, or unexplored in modern chemistry, and processes that can yield unusual results, and even processes that are just repetitions of things that have no immediate change that over long time creates a change. These things are real, even in the most strict chemical / material sense, and don't need showmanship to dress it up. The problem is, these things don't attract much attention, and you can't make a TV special about the supernatural based on the idea that repeated dissolutions and coagulations of some metal salt in water will, over long periods of time slightly change the material characteristics of that salt.

There is another aspect to all these things, a bit of a meta-perspective on us humans, and that is we go through various phases of interacting with our own beliefs as we explore the world around us, the world of ideas, the world of alchemy, the spirit world, our internal world with its various layers, and so on. Often times, progress is made by pigeonholing, that is, by assumption of things as if they were true, which serve as a foot-hold or a rung on a ladder in order to progress our understanding to some other step. Within these types of steps, sometimes treating something as 100% real is important for the development of some next step, and others, from the outside, trying to convince you otherwise is perhaps not helpful for what you are personally going through, as it's not really about the empirical validity of the thing you believe to be true, rather its about that belief inside yourself and the unseen transformations it is undergoing.

@nav2010 none of this is directed towards you or meant to be read in any sort of negative light, it is a light-hearted response to @Pilgrim exploring some concepts related to the divides in belief.
 

nav2010

Occultum
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
752
@Pilgrim past a certain point it becomes easily explainable via the "investment fallacy" aka "sunk cost fallacy". Having expended a certain amount of time and energy in a point of view, abandoning the point of view often translates into feeling one has wasted their time / energy. There is a protectionism measure there too in many cases.

Not saying this is why people choose to continue to believe, or why Nav believes in this case, but it could be part of it in many such similar cases. I think it is more efficient to cut ones losses, and allow a shift in perspective once the bar of proof (or lack thereof) has been met, but therein lies the rub, because for some people, that which meets the bar of proof (or disproof), is not the same as for others. To put it in simple terms, some don't believe in science, or only believe in parts of it, or only those parts they find useful at a certain time. It's all just playing with beliefs, picking and choosing what fits best at certain times, in order to support another belief. Cherry-picked belief laddering. The problem is that as soon as one chooses to use certain evidence as proof, they have to accept that other things that belong to that class of evidence are also legitimate, even if they disprove what they believe. It's a cognitive dissonance then to realize that you aren't basing your beliefs on the proof, you are basing your chosen "proofs" on your pre-existing belief.


I've said it before and I will reiterate it here - alchemy does not need magic tricks, illusionists, con-men, grifters, or any sort of that stuff. That at times it attracts these types is understandable - all "esoteric" systems attract them, and in a larger way, you find these types everywhere that there is possibility of money, fame, power, bolstering the ego, selling things, convincing others, and so on. It's a ubiquitous aspect of human nature.

I think it cheapens the whole thing immensely. It's like the American white house, with all the decorations that are just spray-painted gold. It's fucking tacky and cheap, and only serves to convince certain types, and to many others it's actually deeply repulsive. There are processes that deal with matter that are unconventional, or unexplored in modern chemistry, and processes that can yield unusual results, and even processes that are just repetitions of things that have no immediate change that over long time creates a change. These things are real, even in the most strict chemical / material sense, and don't need showmanship to dress it up. The problem is, these things don't attract much attention, and you can't make a TV special about the supernatural based on the idea that repeated dissolutions and coagulations of some metal salt in water will, over long periods of time slightly change the material characteristics of that salt.

There is another aspect to all these things, a bit of a meta-perspective on us humans, and that is we go through various phases of interacting with our own beliefs as we explore the world around us, the world of ideas, the world of alchemy, the spirit world, our internal world with its various layers, and so on. Often times, progress is made by pigeonholing, that is, by assumption of things as if they were true, which serve as a foot-hold or a rung on a ladder in order to progress our understanding to some other step. Within these types of steps, sometimes treating something as 100% real is important for the development of some next step, and others, from the outside, trying to convince you otherwise is perhaps not helpful for what you are personally going through, as it's not really about the empirical validity of the thing you believe to be true, rather its about that belief inside yourself and the unseen transformations it is undergoing.

@nav2010 none of this is directed towards you or meant to be read in any sort of negative light, it is a light-hearted response to @Pilgrim exploring some concepts related to the divides in belief.
I wasn't particularly interested in what Chamfray was saying but the response of the Spanish contingent. Probably 20 or so of them examining the crucible before and after, a number of chemists and jewellers providing the lead and examining the gold afterwards.
It occurred to me that if this was simply a cheap trick that the Spanish contingent would need to be involved.
Having signed the lead, measured the diameter of the lead wire before and after the transmutation, if this were a trick then those individuals would need to be involved in the illusion or corrupt.
How else can you pull it off? If the lead is signed and a specific diameter and only known to the jewellers and chemists but not Chanfray then the gold wire has the same diameter and signature there are only two possible corruptible answers.
1. The Jewellers and chemists were involved in it and gave Chamfray the exact diameter of the wire and what signature would be marked on the lead so that he could replicate a piece of gold wire to match before any of it took place. He got insider information in other words. This is not impossible but highly unlikely live on TV where important people from the jewellery business and highly reputable chemists would be staking their careers on a cheap con trick. What would be there motive?
2. Chamfray was involved in time travel. He stopped time, measured the lead wire, copied the signature from the lead to the gold so that both the lead and gold wire were identical. Since we know that's not true then if this is a con trick, the Spanish are part of it.
Or.....You can apply Occams razor: When all possibilities have been explored with no outcome, the simple answer is often correct. Chamfray transmuted lead into gold.
 

Pilgrim

Hermes Trismegistus
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 26, 2023
Messages
1,257
The very fact that none of the so-called "experts" expressed surprise when they saw the metal had not melted is proof that they were in on the whole charade. I'm afraid Nav you need to increase your interest in stage magic and prominent magicians like David Blane, David Copperfield and others. It is absolutely normal for large numbers of people, audiences, participators to be in on the trick. Understanding how magic tricks are done enables you to view these kind of stunts with knowing eyes.
 

Lux Natura

Occultum
Honorable Meister
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Aug 25, 2016
Messages
675
@nav2010 all these types of tricks, and many more, are a common part of many illusionists ticks. For example, signing a card, and then the signature is found on a different card. Impossible boxes into which one items goes, and disappears, only for some other item to replace it, even though the magician never touched it. A randomly chosen audience member gives her gold wedding ring to another member, who holds it in his hand for the entire trick, but in the end its found in a locked box which was locked before she took off the ring, and she held the box in her hand the entire time. Lots of stuff like this. It's all well crafted illusion.


Many illusionists do the trick entirely using other people handing the props - they never "touch" the objects, it all occurs in other peoples hands.
 

Lux Natura

Occultum
Honorable Meister
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Aug 25, 2016
Messages
675
Another method this trick could easily be done, which also allows the wire before and after to have the same diameter, and to have the same "marking / engraving" is that it was originally a piece of gold wire that was plated with lead. The lead burns off in the heat of the crucible, but the heat is not strong enough to melt gold. Then you only really need to provide the "lead wire" to the "jeweler" (with or without them knowing, in which case you only need 1 inside man) and that is the whole trick.
 

nav2010

Occultum
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
752
The very fact that none of the so-called "experts" expressed surprise when they saw the metal had not melted is proof that they were in on the whole charade. I'm afraid Nav you need to increase your interest in stage magic and prominent magicians like David Blane, David Copperfield and others. It is absolutely normal for large numbers of people, audiences, participators to be in on the trick. Understanding how magic tricks are done enables you to view these kind of stunts with knowing eyes.
I don't 'need' to do anything.
First you claimed it was a magic trick performed by Chamfray himself then when I've suggested that can't be true because the lead was signed by the jeweller and the identical signature was found on the gold, you've now got a new hypothesis that 'all of them were involved'.
It's now evolved into a 'conspiracy' to defraud. But without motive from the Spanish I might add.
Here on a forum about alchemy, of all the places in the world to claim that alchemy cannot ever happen under no circumstances - and here we stand. Here we stand doubting alchemy itself.
Because you all know don't you?
 

nav2010

Occultum
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
752
I've heard every excuse that it can't be true apart from it was the bunny with the big fluffy ears.
Firstly, it was David Copperfield performing his magic tricks.
Then the whole thing is a conspiracy to defraud the public including Spanish people Chamfray never even knew.
Then another excuse was in volume 32 subsection 3 of Hermes world of transmutation, no lead can be changed into gold unless its melted.
All the while, no one has ever posted a video of a real transmutation and if that is the case, not one single one of you knows how its done yet you talk as if you do. All 'experts' in spotting tricks and all 'experts' in spotting real transmutation when you see it.
No one even gave him the benefit of the doubt and what does that tell me? It tells me none of you really believe in alchemy, not deep down inside of you. In which case what are you doing here?
It's not about if Chamfray is a fraud or not, it has nothing to do with that. It has everything to do with the fact that no one can find a millionth of an ounce of courage to stick their head above the parapet and think - maybe - just maybe and the thing that stops you from doing that is because you don't believe in alchemy.

The thread should be closed mods thank you.
 
Last edited:

Pilgrim

Hermes Trismegistus
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 26, 2023
Messages
1,257
Then the whole thing is a conspiracy to defraud the public including Spanish people Chamfray never even knew.

Nav old bean, go back to post #9.

This TV show, "directisimo" showcased Uri Geller bending spoons. DO you actually believe Geller had a special power to bend spoons ? Are you THAT naive? If not you must concede that this TV episode was indeed a complete defraud of the public. If they were willing to do it with Geller then they would be willing to do it with anyone.

In regards to your statements about alchemy and not knowing how things work, I choose to go by the many many alchemy texts which are the very things after all that have enabled people to engage in this art. Your choice if you want to go in directions not supported by the texts and best of luck, you may ultimately find a new direction.
 

nav2010

Occultum
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
752
Nav old bean, go back to post #9.

This TV show, "directisimo" showcased Uri Geller bending spoons. DO you actually believe Geller had a special power to bend spoons ? Are you THAT naive? If not you must concede that this TV episode was indeed a complete defraud of the public. If they were willing to do it with Geller then they would be willing to do it with anyone.

In regards to your statements about alchemy and not knowing how things work, I choose to go by the many many alchemy texts which are the very things after all that have enabled people to engage in this art. Your choice if you want to go in directions not supported by the texts and best of luck, you may ultimately find a new direction.
Where have I ever mentioned Geller? Only you have, I have no time for Geller or his nonsense you keep bringing up in conversation.
You've chosen alchemical texts that enable people to engage in this art? Show me this engagement, show me a transmutation, show me a tincture which will remove cancer from your arms derived from these texts. Fire away, I'm all ears.
Alchemy is a path we all choose, each man to his own path. I cannot take yours and you cannot take mine either. It can only be a discovery of enlightenment for each person on their journey through their own existence. You've denied Chamfray his own path by your own insistence he hasn't got a path at all. Why? Because of western logic that a man must be a liar at all costs. If a man doesn't fit into your own personal narrative then he must be a liar at all costs.
It's an expensive logic for you personally. Do as you will.
 

Pilgrim

Hermes Trismegistus
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 26, 2023
Messages
1,257
Where have I ever mentioned Geller? Only you have, I have no time for Geller or his nonsense

That's good to know but you fail to make the connection between one episode of "Directisimo" and another or rather fail to apply the same level of skepticism between episodes. It's like knowing exactly how David Copperfield duped audiences into thinking he moved the Statue Of Liberty and then trying to tell everyone that when he walked right through the Great Wall Of China he did it for real. Your critical thinking just isn't rational or consistent here. This is a program that wilfully gives a platform to con artists and you're trying to attribute some kind of special exception to all it's so-called "experts" in one specific episode just because it fits your personal paradigm or comfort zone. I think differently. If I know this TV show will happily put the likes of Geller on it then I make the base assumption that the same TV show is likely to put other similar people on it. In other words it's not a serious and safe platform to use as any basis of fact or scientific or paranormal claims.

Understand that this is not any kind of criticism of alchemy itself, it's purely a criticism of a dubious TV show and a dubious demonstration performed on that dubious TV show.

You've denied Chamfray his own path by your own insistence he hasn't got a path at all. Why?

I haven't denied this at all. I've simply made comment on a dubious demonstration and claim performed on a dubious TV show.
However one doesn't need to dig very far into Chanfray's past to understand much about his life and that it really doesn't seem at all like one of either an immortal or an alchemist who has the Stone.

From https://en-academic.com/dic.nsf/enwiki/1795904

"He was born in 4 Aprile 1940 in the French city of Lyon. His childhood was spent on the streets and he became a thief. Arrested for assaulting a woman during a robbery and sentenced to six years, he read some antique books in prison, and learned about Comte de Saint-Germain, the mysterious alchemist, who claimed to be capable of transmutating lead into gold, brewing potions, and acquiring immortality. Chanfray adopted that personality, using French high society's fondness for magic, esoterism and hermeticism. He quickly became rich and well-known through his exploits, for example giving divinations and psychic readings to various famous people as well as through his outlandish claims.

In 1972 he met the singer Dalida, at the height of her fame. Her husband, Lucien Morisse, and her lover, Luigi Tenco, had both previously committed suicide. When Dalida met Chanfray, she quickly became infatuated. She recognized his paranoia, however: he slept with a shotgun under his bed. He also spent another year in prison, as well as being forced to pay FF formatnum:500000 restitution, when he shot a man whom he found naked in his kitchen late one night. The man was only superficially wounded, and turned out to be the servant's lover.

The incident marked the start of his decline. The couple ran out of money and Chanfray attempted music, painting, and sculpture, all without success. Dalida and Chanfray separated, but despite his problems, he continued to be a part of the celebrity society of Paris and Saint Tropez. He became the lover of the Trintignan "baroness", Paula de Loos, whose title was as false as his own. De Loos was, however, allegedly a millionaire and when Chanfray began to suspect the activities of de Loos's financial administrator, he threatened him with a rifle. He was again imprisoned and fined -- to which he looked to de Loos for help. She, however, was also heavily in debt.

He last appeared in public at a party in Saint Tropez, in June 1983. He was reportedly very thin, with white hair and an exhausted appearance.

On the 14th of July 1983, in a town near Saint Tropez, Chanfray and de Loos ingested barbiturates while inhaling the exhaust of his car. Nearby was a suicide note that read: "I leave and I bring her with me, because she is so like me..." "


There is nothing here that remotely suggests to me that Chanfray was a genuine alchemist. Started out on the streets, a theif, six years in prison and then suddenly adopting the persona of someone else on release, becoming a psychic. Note that he "ran out of money" in later life, which for someone who allegedly could turn lead into gold makes no sense whatsoever. Also his health began to deteriorate in the 80s which again, for someone who allegedly had the Stone makes no sense at all. Finally committing suicide by putting a hose from his car exhaust into his car and breathing carbon monoxide and taking barbiturates and this at the young age of 43.
Sorry but just no. This all suggests a chancer, playboy and Geller like showman, not a genuine alchemist.



Because of western logic that a man must be a liar at all costs. If a man doesn't fit into your own personal narrative then he must be a liar at all costs.

Nope. The simple logic is that a man with the Stone does not decline in health but has very good health and does not become poor but rather can become rich or simply make enough to get by without attracting attention.


It's an expensive logic for you personally. Do as you will.
It's not at all expensive. It's simple critical thinking and such helps keep the charlatans away from my life journey.
 

nav2010

Occultum
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
752
That's good to know but you fail to make the connection between one episode of "Directisimo" and another or rather fail to apply the same level of skepticism between episodes. It's like knowing exactly how David Copperfield duped audiences into thinking he moved the Statue Of Liberty and then trying to tell everyone that when he walked right through the Great Wall Of China he did it for real. Your critical thinking just isn't rational or consistent here. This is a program that wilfully gives a platform to con artists and you're trying to attribute some kind of special exception to all it's so-called "experts" in one specific episode just because it fits your personal paradigm or comfort zone. I think differently. If I know this TV show will happily put the likes of Geller on it then I make the base assumption that the same TV show is likely to put other similar people on it. In other words it's not a serious and safe platform to use as any basis of fact or scientific or paranormal claims.

Understand that this is not any kind of criticism of alchemy itself, it's purely a criticism of a dubious TV show and a dubious demonstration performed on that dubious TV show.



I haven't denied this at all. I've simply made comment on a dubious demonstration and claim performed on a dubious TV show.
However one doesn't need to dig very far into Chanfray's past to understand much about his life and that it really doesn't seem at all like one of either an immortal or an alchemist who has the Stone.

From https://en-academic.com/dic.nsf/enwiki/1795904

"He was born in 4 Aprile 1940 in the French city of Lyon. His childhood was spent on the streets and he became a thief. Arrested for assaulting a woman during a robbery and sentenced to six years, he read some antique books in prison, and learned about Comte de Saint-Germain, the mysterious alchemist, who claimed to be capable of transmutating lead into gold, brewing potions, and acquiring immortality. Chanfray adopted that personality, using French high society's fondness for magic, esoterism and hermeticism. He quickly became rich and well-known through his exploits, for example giving divinations and psychic readings to various famous people as well as through his outlandish claims.

In 1972 he met the singer Dalida, at the height of her fame. Her husband, Lucien Morisse, and her lover, Luigi Tenco, had both previously committed suicide. When Dalida met Chanfray, she quickly became infatuated. She recognized his paranoia, however: he slept with a shotgun under his bed. He also spent another year in prison, as well as being forced to pay FF formatnum:500000 restitution, when he shot a man whom he found naked in his kitchen late one night. The man was only superficially wounded, and turned out to be the servant's lover.

The incident marked the start of his decline. The couple ran out of money and Chanfray attempted music, painting, and sculpture, all without success. Dalida and Chanfray separated, but despite his problems, he continued to be a part of the celebrity society of Paris and Saint Tropez. He became the lover of the Trintignan "baroness", Paula de Loos, whose title was as false as his own. De Loos was, however, allegedly a millionaire and when Chanfray began to suspect the activities of de Loos's financial administrator, he threatened him with a rifle. He was again imprisoned and fined -- to which he looked to de Loos for help. She, however, was also heavily in debt.

He last appeared in public at a party in Saint Tropez, in June 1983. He was reportedly very thin, with white hair and an exhausted appearance.


On the 14th of July 1983, in a town near Saint Tropez, Chanfray and de Loos ingested barbiturates while inhaling the exhaust of his car. Nearby was a suicide note that read: "I leave and I bring her with me, because she is so like me..." "


There is nothing here that remotely suggests to me that Chanfray was a genuine alchemist. Started out on the streets, a theif, six years in prison and then suddenly adopting the persona of someone else on release, becoming a psychic. Note that he "ran out of money" in later life, which for someone who allegedly could turn lead into gold makes no sense whatsoever. Also his health began to deteriorate in the 80s which again, for someone who allegedly had the Stone makes no sense at all. Finally committing suicide by putting a hose from his car exhaust into his car and breathing carbon monoxide and taking barbiturates and this at the young age of 43.
Sorry but just no. This all suggests a chancer, playboy and Geller like showman, not a genuine alchemist.





Nope. The simple logic is that a man with the Stone does not decline in health but has very good health and does not become poor but rather can become rich or simply make enough to get by without attracting attention.



It's not at all expensive. It's simple critical thinking and such helps keep the charlatans away from my life journey.
Copying someone else's perception of Chamfray from Wiki doesn't answer any questions. It only bolsters your own perception that he is a liar. Where does that perception come from? It comes from western logic that destroyers of a personal narrative must be liars at all cost.
Yet at the same time your own narrative has no basis in which to accuse anyone of being a liar in the first place.
I'll ask you again from the previous post where you claimed you've chosen alchemical texts that enable people to engage in this art.
Show this engagement, show me transmutations and show me the stone curing an illness.
If you cannot show any of this then you have absolutely no idea how alchemy works and you are NOT IN ANY POSITION MORALLY OR OTHERWISE TO CALL ANYONE A LIAR. Fire away, I'm all ears.
 

Pilgrim

Hermes Trismegistus
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 26, 2023
Messages
1,257
Copying someone else's perception of Chamfray from Wiki doesn't answer any questions.

Which parts of the report do you believe are someone's perceptions as opposed to confirmed facts?

Do you believe he was not French?
Do you believe he wasn't born in 1940 or not born in Lyon?
Do you believe he wasn't actually found dead in his car havng put a hose on his exhaust to kill himslef?
 

nav2010

Occultum
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
752
Which parts of the report do you believe are someone's perceptions as opposed to confirmed facts?

Do you believe he was not French?
Do you believe he wasn't born in 1940 or not born in Lyon?
Do you believe he wasn't actually found dead in his car havng put a hose on his exhaust to kill himslef?
You'd need to show birth certificates, death certificates or anything concerning his life.
I could say the same about my wife, she was born in Lyon in 1940, was French and committed suicide in 1983. Hardly, she's sat at the side of me as we speak and her native tongue is English.
It says KFC on the side of buses but they don't sell it do they?
 

Pilgrim

Hermes Trismegistus
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 26, 2023
Messages
1,257
OK, so I conclude that your position is an untennable one and that we won't benefit from further exchanges on the matter.
In one breath you won't believe a claimed fact unless it is accompanied by documentation like certificates and death papers, and in the other breath you're willing to take at face value a TV presentation of an alleged transmutation on a show that has also featured people like Geller. Why are you not demanding spectrographic analyses of the lead that was used in the TV show? Why are you willing to believe the word or indeed if we're being truthful, the perception of a so-called expert on a TV show and yet won't believe posted facts about the history of Chanfray? It's a kind of confirmation bias.

And again, I still ask, why does a tiny piece of lead wire not melt when subjected to the heat of a gas burner for over 4 minutes? You've ignored this throughout.
 

nav2010

Occultum
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
752
OK, so I conclude that your position is an untennable one and that we won't benefit from further exchanges on the matter.
In one breath you won't believe a claimed fact unless it is accompanied by documentation like certificates and death papers, and in the other breath you're willing to take at face value a TV presentation of an alleged transmutation on a show that has also featured people like Geller. Why are you not demanding spectrographic analyses of the lead that was used in the TV show? Why are you willing to believe the word or indeed if we're being truthful, the perception of a so-called expert on a TV show and yet won't believe posted facts about the history of Chanfray? It's a kind of confirmation bias.

And again, I still ask, why does a tiny piece of lead wire not melt when subjected to the heat of a gas burner for over 4 minutes? You've ignored this throughout.
What on earth is a claimed fact? That's a new one. Do you mean a fact that can no longer be a fact because it cannot be verified?
A claimed fact must be a rumour yes?
We are back to 'facts' again from 'claimed facts' as you progress through your post?
The stuff you posted can only be fact if you post concrete evidence to back it up with so its just rumours you posted about Chamfray isn't it, not fact?
Regarding the lead not melting, I asked that very question at the beginning of the thread.
I'll tell you some facts free of charge:-
1. Fact one, you have never been involved in transmutation or seen it for yourself and you have never seen the stone cure someone of illness.
2. Fact two, because of fact one you are in no position to call anyone a liar concerning transmutation because you don't even know how its done yourself.
3. You've failed to show me on this thread anyone performing transmutation or healing people with alchemy so how do you know Chamfray is wrong?
4. You've claimed Chamfray is a liar and a cheat, I haven't accused him of anything, I just posted the Spanish show and you laid straight into him because he had to be a liar at all costs not quite fitting into Pilgrims narrative. How strange of you.
 

Pilgrim

Hermes Trismegistus
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 26, 2023
Messages
1,257
Regarding the lead not melting, I asked that very question at the beginning of the thread.
No you didn't, at the least I can not see where you did.


I'll tell you some facts free of charge:-
1. Fact one, you have never been involved in transmutation or seen it for yourself and you have never seen the stone cure someone of illness.
irrelevent to my question, why does the tiny piece of lead not melt after over 4 minutes of heating?

2. Fact two, because of fact one you are in no position to call anyone a liar concerning transmutation because you don't even know how its done yourself.
irrelevent to my question, why does the tiny piece of lead not melt after over 4 minutes of heating?

3. You've failed to show me on this thread anyone performing transmutation or healing people with alchemy so how do you know Chamfray is wrong?
irrelevent to my question, why does the tiny piece of lead not melt after over 4 minutes of heating?

4. You've claimed Chamfray is a liar and a cheat, I haven't accused him of anything, I just posted the Spanish show and you laid straight into him because he had to be a liar at all costs not quite fitting into Pilgrims narrative. How strange of you.
irrelevent to my question, why does the tiny piece of lead not melt after over 4 minutes of heating?

You're engaging in evasion. That's intellectually dishonest. You are better than this.

Why does the tiny piece of lead not melt after over 4 minutes of heating? It's against basic physics.
 

nav2010

Occultum
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
752
No you didn't, at the least I can not see where you did.



irrelevent to my question, why does the tiny piece of lead not melt after over 4 minutes of heating?


irrelevent to my question, why does the tiny piece of lead not melt after over 4 minutes of heating?


irrelevent to my question, why does the tiny piece of lead not melt after over 4 minutes of heating?


irrelevent to my question, why does the tiny piece of lead not melt after over 4 minutes of heating?

You're engaging in evasion. That's intellectually dishonest. You are better than this.

Why does the tiny piece of lead not melt after over 4 minutes of heating? It's against basic physics.
Because it turned to gold before the melting point of lead was reached.
Now show me a transmutation and I think you should apologise to Richard for what you've said about him, it's not nice is it?
 

nav2010

Occultum
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 5, 2010
Messages
752
There are no basic physics in alchemy. There is only what is not understood in chemistry and vice versa, what is not understood in alchemy.
If you melt lead as per the Sage's scripts and heat it to 350c then add projection powder, the melted gold must instantly reach a temperature of 1063c for it to constitute melted gold. An increase of over 700c in a millisecond. In classical chemistry and physics this breaks the laws of thermodynamics because according to those laws you cannot create energy from nothing.
And here you sit Pilgrim, claiming to have read those scripts and understood them knowing that it breaks the laws of thermodynamics for lead to turn into gold and then in the most hypocritical statement of the 21st century, you claim Chamfray is breaking 'basic physics' which are the same basic physics principles the Sage's break. Tut tut, it just won't do will it.
I don't deny the Sages anything, I don't deny Chamfray anything but you do, that's why we are worlds apart.
 

Pilgrim

Hermes Trismegistus
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 26, 2023
Messages
1,257
Because it turned to gold before the melting point of lead was reached.
If this is true, and it is speculation of course, then why does the transmutation require heat at all?
 

Pilgrim

Hermes Trismegistus
Hermetic Pilgrim
Joined
Apr 26, 2023
Messages
1,257
If you melt lead as per the Sage's scripts and heat it to 350c then add projection powder, the melted gold must instantly reach a temperature of 1063c for it to constitute melted gold.
But it wouldn't need to become melted gold. As soon as the molten lead transmutes it would just become solid gold at 350 degrees C